October 2006   

In This Issue:
       Stage 4 Solutions In Action
San Jose Business Journal

Not All Customers Are Equal - Understanding Customer Profitability

>> Back to List
San Jose Business Journal
Stage 4 Solutions and Niti Agrawal were featured in the San Jose Business Journal on September 29, 2006. The focus of the article is on Stage 4 Solutions’ success as an product marketing consulting firm, and on the tremendous growth that has been achieved this year. Stage 4 Solutions has experienced double digit growth year after year since it’s inception in 2001. Niti attributes this success to the company culture of communication and follow through, the strong marketing expertise of her consultants, and a commitment to client success. The company has achieved 100% client referenceability and continues to grow.
The article also discusses Stage 4 Solutions’ recently released research study on outsourced marketing. To read the article, "Consultant Spots", rides marketing’s latest wave, please click here.

       Thought Leadership
Not All Customers Are Equal - Understanding Customer Profitability
Understanding what it costs to serve your customers, and which customers are more or less costly to serve is a strategic component to achieving profitability. While all companies know their bottom line profitability and their net profit by month, quarter and year, they probably do not understand profitability by customer - especially in the area of services. Service costs are particularly difficult to quantify and tie to specific services delivered, because there are more shared costs among customers, and employee costs are typically not tracked against services delivered and by customer.

Service businesses don’t truly understand which customers cost more to serve than others, and which customers use fewer resources, so in fact are more profitable. The type of financial information necessary to determine the cost to service a customer is typically not available through financial accounting systems or management tools, and often proves to be a significant challenge to pull together. However, this detailed and involved process may possibly be the most critical determination to business success. Without this knowledge, service businesses run as if blindfolded.

If companies understood profitability by customer and customer segment, they could manage their businesses far more effectively, and develop strategies to:
  • Target the "right" most profitable customers segments
  • Price services to yield consistent gross margins across customers
  • Discount sales to specific customers
  • Design promotional bundles and service bundles
Service organizations, in short, could be a lot smarter about how to run their entire service business and plan for the future. For a recent client, Stage 4 Solutions, developed a customer profitability analysis and scenario planning model, which provided great insight into customer profitability and resource usage. In developing the customer profitability model, we defined and analyzed several key factors:

Revenue by Customer:
  • Sales revenue by customer is typically available through a sales force system or an order management system
Services Delivered:
  • All services that are delivered to customers need to be categorized as discrete activities. For each identified service, a "cost driver" must be associated. A cost driver is a transaction that can be used to "count" the number of services transactions provided (or the volume of services provided).
Total Cost by Service:
  • All salary and non-salary costs need to be divided into the service types identified.
Overhead Costs:
  • Overhead costs may or may not be allocated back to each customer. There are several different overhead allocation methodologies to employ if that decision is made. Often, the analysis is best done at customer contribution margin; which is customer revenue less the costs to deliver services associated with that revenue.
Defining and analyzing each of these facets requires a great deal of thought and cross-functional buy-in to develop a meaningful analysis.

For many organizations, a customer profitability analysis is a one-time or, at best periodic event. The sporadic nature of such analysis is because few, if any, traditional ERP or other accounting solutions are developed to support such categorizations of costs, time, service types and cost drivers. However, some innovative solutions in this area are being developed by technology start-ups. For lasting value, such solutions must be adopted so that customer profitability becomes an integral part of a service business’ decision making and strategy development processes.

If you are interested in learning more about the cost to serve methodology or would like help in developing a customer profitability model for your business, please contact Stage 4 Solutions at (408) 868-9739 -